Customer Claim Information

Listed below you will find phone numbers for direct claim reporting for many of our insurance companies. These numbers are provided to you for your assistance in after hours claim reporting.

We would request that if you report a claim directly to the company that you still contact our office at your earliest convenience to advise us of the claim. We will work directly with the carrier to settle your claim.

Our office telephone number is 845-896-2222.

Peerless Insurance
To report a claim:
Phone (800) 522-7152

Safeco Insurance www.safeco.com
To report a claim:
Phone (800) 332-3226

Travelors Insurance www.travelers.com
To report a claim:
Phone (800) 252-4633

Preferred Mutual Insurance Company www.pminsco.com
To report a claim:
Phone (800) 333-7642

Progressive Insurance www.progressive.com
To report a claim:
Phone (800) 274-4499

Farmers Insurance Group www.farmers.com
To report a claim:
Phone (800) 435-7764

The Main Street America Group www.msagroup.com
To report a claim:
Phone (877) 4CLAIMS (877-425-2467)

Zurich Insurance www.zurichna.com
To report a claim:
Phone (800) 987-3373